I applied to the Master’s of City Planning program at MIT and I didn’t get in.

The failure

Being rejected from the program.

Why do I call this a failure / what would it have meant for it to be a success

I feel some need to be credentialed in planning or policy for future work I want to do. But it’s very possible this is less important than I think, and really in thinking this way I’m exercising a chip on my shoulder.

MIT specifically fits a lot of the ethos of what I care about (planning fundamentally, but with an eye for technology and innovation), the reputation is strong, and doing the program while here would have been efficient.

What did I do wrong

I could have spent more time on the Essay and especially on the portfolio. I had a second version of the portfolio that was much better and I did upload it a week or so later. But I’m not sure if they looked at it.

This was a very rushed period of the semester as I was also applying to the MIT/SDM master’s (maybe I should have waited until the second deadline for that and focused on the MCP)

What is a lesson I learned from this experiment / who can benefit from this lesson

Not sure there’s a huge lesson here. Maybe give more time to things you think you’ll feel bad about not having spent more time on later.

I know the odds were low of getting this, but I still had a part of me over-believing in my chance. Not too upset all things considered, but I think that dissonance exists to some degree.

I think that dissonance comes from some belief that I am able to do something, and feel that I could even be more capable than many who actually are there.

Perhaps this is over confidence, a chip on my shoulder, or what have you. But it’s an interesting feeling to explore.

I think this feeling also comes up during job rejections, but I guess you live with that possibility for less time.

What’s a benefit that’s come from this failure?

I have an opportunity to massage the chip on my shoulder and focus on the actual work rather than on the credential. At least for now.

It’s also possible I could apply again next year, or to another program, but I don’t know if it’s really worth it later on. We’ll see.